Martha's Vineyard is a culinary haven, offering a diverse array of dining experiences that capture the island's rich cultural heritage and coastal charm. Whether you're in search of upscale dining, casual eateries, or vibrant nightlife, this guide will help you discover the best restaurants, cafes, and bars across all six towns.

Edgartown

Edgartown blends historic New England charm with some of the island’s most polished dining rooms. From oyster bars to French-inspired fine dining, this town delivers high-quality meals in iconic waterfront settings.

Top Dining Spots in Edgartown (Verified 2025)

• The Port Hunter: Oysters, creative cocktails & live music (55 Main St)
• 19 Raw Oyster Bar: #1 Seafood Restaurant 2025 — Island-famous oysters (19 Church St)
• L'etoile: French fine dining (Thu–Sat) — Perfect for special occasions
• The Terrace at Harbor View Hotel: Luxury harbor-view dining with elevated coastal dishes

Culinary Events

Martha’s Vineyard Food & Wine Festival: Every October — chef demos, exclusive tastings & wine pairings.

Oak Bluffs

Oak Bluffs is vibrant, diverse, and packed with energy. From award-winning chowder to iconic fried clams and nightlife, it’s a must-visit culinary town.

Must-Try Restaurants in Oak Bluffs (Verified 2025)

• Martha's Vineyard Chowder Company: BEST CHOWDER 2025 + gluten-free broth
• Giordano’s: BEST FRIED CLAMS 2025 — old-school island classic
• Coop de Ville: BEST WINGS 2025 — wharf-side drinks & casual seafood
• The Red Cat Kitchen: Art-filled bistro serving creative farm-to-table dishes
• Sweet Life Café: Upscale creative dining with a garden patio
• Lookout Tavern: Lobster rolls, sushi & sunset harbor views

Nightlife

Lookout Tavern and nearby bars create some of the most energetic nightlife on the island, especially during summer evenings.

Vineyard Haven

Known for its year-round community, Vineyard Haven’s dining scene mixes iconic establishments with exciting new openings.

Dining Highlights in Vineyard Haven (Verified 2025)

• Garde East: Luxury waterfront dining — Best views in VH
• Beach Road: Modern American dishes with island-sourced ingredients
• Black Dog Tavern: Iconic New England comfort food with harbor views
• El Barco: BEST NEW RESTAURANT 2025 — tacos, ceviche, birria
• 9 Craft Kitchen: Runner-up best new restaurant — lobster risotto & coastal comfort dishes

Chilmark & West Tisbury (Up-Island)

The heart of the island’s farm-to-table movement — peaceful rural settings, farmers markets, and legendary up-island cuisine.

Notable Dining Experiences (Verified 2025)

• State Road Restaurant: #1 Farm-to-Table dining on Martha’s Vineyard (688 State Rd)
• Grey Barn Creamery: Award-winning cheeses, baked goods, and local products
• North Tisbury Farm & Market: BEST FARM STORE 2025 — sandwiches, pastries, produce
• West Tisbury Farmers Market: Island’s top market for local produce & artisanal goods
• Beach Plum Inn: Menemsha sunsets + fine dining

Katama

A coastal neighborhood in Edgartown known for beach-forward dining and wide-open ocean views.

Beachfront Dining

• The Dunes at Winnetu Oceanside Resort: Panoramic ocean views, fresh seafood, cocktails
• Right Fork Diner: Breakfast & dinner with views of small plane takeoffs

Aquinnah

Home to the dramatic clay cliffs and quiet dining with unforgettable sunset views.

Unique Dining Spots

• Outermost Inn: Cliffside fine dining — one of the best sunset meals in New England
• Aquinnah Circle Eateries: Casual chowder, lobster rolls, tacos & local vendors

Menemsha

A working fishing village known for the freshest seafood on the island.

Seafood Delights (Verified 2025)

• Larsen’s Fish Market: Fresh catch, steamed lobster & chowder
• Menemsha Fish Market: Grilled bluefish, chowder, lobster rolls
• The Galley: Burgers, ice cream & shakes

FAQs

• What are the must-visit dining spots in Edgartown? The Port Hunter, 19 Raw, L’Etoile & The Terrace.
• Is Oak Bluffs good for nightlife? Yes — Lookout Tavern, Coop de Ville & Circuit Ave energy.
• Best seafood on the island? 19 Raw (Edgartown) + Menemsha fish markets.
• Where to enjoy farm-to-table? State Road Restaurant & Grey Barn Creamery.

Explore Martha's Vineyard’s Culinary Scene

Martha’s Vineyard offers one of the most diverse coastal dining scenes in New England. Whether you're exploring fine dining, waterfront restaurants, oyster bars, or casual seafood shacks, every town brings something unique. Visit MV Vacation for more guides, insider tips, and the latest 2025 dining updates.